/ hhrangeexpert80's Library/ Notes/ Guan Yu lost Jingzhou and retreated to Maicheng around the border of Yizhou. Why didn’t Liu Bei send troops to rescue him.txt
Guan Yu lost Jingzhou and retreated to Maicheng around the border of Yizhou. Why didn’t Liu Bei send troops to rescue him.txt
from web site
Guan Yu's defeat is an irreversible loss for Liu Bei Group.
From then on, not just did Zhu Geliang’s Longzhong Dui, the strategic arranging with the attack from Hanzhong out of Longxi and in the direction of Jingzhou north, went bankrupt, but additionally was trapped inside the moral abduction of Taoist friendship among Liu Guanzhang and Zhang Liu, and Liu Bei launched it later. Within the battle of Yiling, the family members of Shuhan was lost.
Considering driver recovery software that Guan Yu's life and death and Jingzhou's gains and losses were so essential to Liu Bei Group, when Guan Yu fought with Cao Cao on the front lines of Fancheng and Xiangyang till he was caught by Soochow Lumeng, he retreated and broke through to Maicheng, only a few tens of miles away from Yizhou. At that time, why have in no way seen the rescue response from Liu Bei?
To solve this puzzle, we should initially clarify the geographical error between Liu Bei and Guan Yu.
Maicheng is certainly quite close for the border of Yizhou, but the most important force of Liu Bei's base camp in Chengdu is tough to overcome Guan Yu's thirst from afar.
Due to the fact ancient instances, the difficulty of your Shu Road has been difficult to attain the blue sky. Liu Bei from Chengdu to Jingzhou, if there is not adequate time for the layout of soldiers, horses, grains and ordnance, there's no relative response to Guan Yu in a hurry.
Guan Yu launched the Battle of Xiangfan in July on the 24th year of Jian'an (219 years). At http://www.google.com , Liu Bei just ended the Hanzhong battle with Cao Cao two years ago. Despite the fact that he defeated Cao Jun to win Hanzhong, Liu Bei itself also spent quite a bit of strength and needed a period of rest and replenishment.
It was precisely at this time that Xiangfan's frontline reported fantastic news frequently. Guan Yu flooded the Seventh Army, captured the forbidden, and slashed Pound, striking Cao Cao's elite troops, Megatron China, and also the world's invincible momentum. It appears that without the need of any external force, it could smooth the road. Cao Jun.
Additionally, within the past handful of years due to the fact Liu Bei’s battle with all the Red Cliffs, based on Jingzhou, Zhanyizhou, and Hanzhong, they have succeeded, and also the power has expanded considerably. The pride and complacency from the entire group has grown day by day, and most of them are concerned about Guan Yu’s battle in Xiangfan. Optimistic mentality.
Additionally, in between Jingzhou and Yizhou, Liu Bei isn't without defense. Inside the upper middle of the border in between the two areas, Liu Feng and Meng Da's troops are arranged to support Guan Yu in Xiangfan at any time. Even when the battle situation on Guan Yu's side changes, Yizhou's side can let Liu Feng and Meng Da delay the battle very first, so as to have enough time for the rescue of significant troops.
The above components are superimposed to provide the Liu Bei Group a incorrect signal-Guan Yu's Jingzhou front doesn't require to be specially reinforced.
What surprised Liu Bei unexpectedly was that Soochow Sun Quan had torn Sun and Liu Alliance, sent Lumeng to cross the river in white, speedily attacked the base camp behind Guan Yu, and formed a pinch against Guan Yu's troops in Xiangfan. From July to December in the twenty-four years of Jian'an (219), the victory and defeat of Xiangfan changed significantly in just 4 months.
At this time, Liu Bei, even when he immediately ordered the soldiers to rush to Jingzhou, it was too late to rescue Guan Yu.
What's much more terrible is the fact that the original layout was specially designed to cope together with the Liuyong and Mengda departments in Yizhou and Jingzhou. They basically did not play their due part. Seeing Guan Yu's defeat in Maicheng close to getting captured No rescue was sent from starting to finish.
Right here, possibly also associated to Yu individual reasons.
Guan Yu ranks very first among the generals on the 5 Tigers, and his position within the Liu Bei Group is often described as above 10,000 under one particular person, but he's also arrogant in temperament and often doesn't get along nicely with his colleagues.
Even Sun Quan, who occupies Jiangdong and has the friendship of an alliance, doesn't give face to him. Inside the face of Sun Quan's request for marriage, he even jumped out, 'My tiger girl is prepared to marry a dog!' Put it on other individuals, let alone anticipate Guan Yu to give a good face.
Guan Yu, whose character determines his destiny and lack of EQ, continues to be a provocative master. Seeing that Liu Bei defeated Cao Cao in Hanzhong, he believed that he had to take action in Jingzhou, so he hurriedly launched the Xiangfan War.
Judging from the situation at that time, Liu Bei had just ended the battle amongst Hanzhong and suffered a critical loss of strength. Moreover, inside the Hanzhong territory that was won, the majority of the people today inside had been removed by Cao Cao, unable to supplement Liu Beijun’s horse, so it was not appropriate for launching a large-scale battle like the Xiangfan Battle.
In the viewpoint from the whole Liu Bei Group, Guan Yu’s part in defending Jingzhou was to attack Cao Wei from the northwest plus the south, causing Cao Cao to fall in to the predicament of two-line combat, and he couldn't look after each.
However, Guan Yu did not send troops when Liu Bei and Cao Cao had been still confronting Hanzhong. Instead, they waited till Cao Cao's northwest front was stabilized to launch the Xiangfan battle, which made the original two-sided attack technique in the type.
Much more subtly, the Liu Bei Group won Yizhou and Hanzhong, collectively with the former Jingzhou occupation, the all round strength has risen sharply, which has already broken the preceding strength comparison with Soochow. Sun Quan guards against Cao Cao, and now he is a lot more guarded against the growing Liu Bei. Sun Liu Alliance has alternatively turned to Sun Cao Alliance.
Guan Yu chose to launch the Xiangfan campaign at this time, and dispatched a sizable number of troops towards the front line, which is equivalent to leaving an empty rear to Soochow. Why does Sun Quan not pick up low cost!
It might be seen from this that the entire Xiangfan battle was a wrong battle launched by Liu Bei Group for a lot of years with smooth sailing and euphoria. The outcome abruptly fell a major heel, not to mention the loss with the common Guan Yu, even the strategic pattern, was also replayed back to the weakest state of Wei Shu Wu three-legged in the state of Shu.
From then on, not just did Zhu Geliang’s Longzhong Dui, the strategic arranging with the attack from Hanzhong out of Longxi and in the direction of Jingzhou north, went bankrupt, but additionally was trapped inside the moral abduction of Taoist friendship among Liu Guanzhang and Zhang Liu, and Liu Bei launched it later. Within the battle of Yiling, the family members of Shuhan was lost.
Considering driver recovery software that Guan Yu's life and death and Jingzhou's gains and losses were so essential to Liu Bei Group, when Guan Yu fought with Cao Cao on the front lines of Fancheng and Xiangyang till he was caught by Soochow Lumeng, he retreated and broke through to Maicheng, only a few tens of miles away from Yizhou. At that time, why have in no way seen the rescue response from Liu Bei?
To solve this puzzle, we should initially clarify the geographical error between Liu Bei and Guan Yu.
Maicheng is certainly quite close for the border of Yizhou, but the most important force of Liu Bei's base camp in Chengdu is tough to overcome Guan Yu's thirst from afar.
Due to the fact ancient instances, the difficulty of your Shu Road has been difficult to attain the blue sky. Liu Bei from Chengdu to Jingzhou, if there is not adequate time for the layout of soldiers, horses, grains and ordnance, there's no relative response to Guan Yu in a hurry.
Guan Yu launched the Battle of Xiangfan in July on the 24th year of Jian'an (219 years). At http://www.google.com , Liu Bei just ended the Hanzhong battle with Cao Cao two years ago. Despite the fact that he defeated Cao Jun to win Hanzhong, Liu Bei itself also spent quite a bit of strength and needed a period of rest and replenishment.
It was precisely at this time that Xiangfan's frontline reported fantastic news frequently. Guan Yu flooded the Seventh Army, captured the forbidden, and slashed Pound, striking Cao Cao's elite troops, Megatron China, and also the world's invincible momentum. It appears that without the need of any external force, it could smooth the road. Cao Jun.
Additionally, within the past handful of years due to the fact Liu Bei’s battle with all the Red Cliffs, based on Jingzhou, Zhanyizhou, and Hanzhong, they have succeeded, and also the power has expanded considerably. The pride and complacency from the entire group has grown day by day, and most of them are concerned about Guan Yu’s battle in Xiangfan. Optimistic mentality.
Additionally, in between Jingzhou and Yizhou, Liu Bei isn't without defense. Inside the upper middle of the border in between the two areas, Liu Feng and Meng Da's troops are arranged to support Guan Yu in Xiangfan at any time. Even when the battle situation on Guan Yu's side changes, Yizhou's side can let Liu Feng and Meng Da delay the battle very first, so as to have enough time for the rescue of significant troops.
The above components are superimposed to provide the Liu Bei Group a incorrect signal-Guan Yu's Jingzhou front doesn't require to be specially reinforced.
What surprised Liu Bei unexpectedly was that Soochow Sun Quan had torn Sun and Liu Alliance, sent Lumeng to cross the river in white, speedily attacked the base camp behind Guan Yu, and formed a pinch against Guan Yu's troops in Xiangfan. From July to December in the twenty-four years of Jian'an (219), the victory and defeat of Xiangfan changed significantly in just 4 months.
At this time, Liu Bei, even when he immediately ordered the soldiers to rush to Jingzhou, it was too late to rescue Guan Yu.
What's much more terrible is the fact that the original layout was specially designed to cope together with the Liuyong and Mengda departments in Yizhou and Jingzhou. They basically did not play their due part. Seeing Guan Yu's defeat in Maicheng close to getting captured No rescue was sent from starting to finish.
Right here, possibly also associated to Yu individual reasons.
Guan Yu ranks very first among the generals on the 5 Tigers, and his position within the Liu Bei Group is often described as above 10,000 under one particular person, but he's also arrogant in temperament and often doesn't get along nicely with his colleagues.
Even Sun Quan, who occupies Jiangdong and has the friendship of an alliance, doesn't give face to him. Inside the face of Sun Quan's request for marriage, he even jumped out, 'My tiger girl is prepared to marry a dog!' Put it on other individuals, let alone anticipate Guan Yu to give a good face.
Guan Yu, whose character determines his destiny and lack of EQ, continues to be a provocative master. Seeing that Liu Bei defeated Cao Cao in Hanzhong, he believed that he had to take action in Jingzhou, so he hurriedly launched the Xiangfan War.
Judging from the situation at that time, Liu Bei had just ended the battle amongst Hanzhong and suffered a critical loss of strength. Moreover, inside the Hanzhong territory that was won, the majority of the people today inside had been removed by Cao Cao, unable to supplement Liu Beijun’s horse, so it was not appropriate for launching a large-scale battle like the Xiangfan Battle.
In the viewpoint from the whole Liu Bei Group, Guan Yu’s part in defending Jingzhou was to attack Cao Wei from the northwest plus the south, causing Cao Cao to fall in to the predicament of two-line combat, and he couldn't look after each.
However, Guan Yu did not send troops when Liu Bei and Cao Cao had been still confronting Hanzhong. Instead, they waited till Cao Cao's northwest front was stabilized to launch the Xiangfan battle, which made the original two-sided attack technique in the type.
Much more subtly, the Liu Bei Group won Yizhou and Hanzhong, collectively with the former Jingzhou occupation, the all round strength has risen sharply, which has already broken the preceding strength comparison with Soochow. Sun Quan guards against Cao Cao, and now he is a lot more guarded against the growing Liu Bei. Sun Liu Alliance has alternatively turned to Sun Cao Alliance.
Guan Yu chose to launch the Xiangfan campaign at this time, and dispatched a sizable number of troops towards the front line, which is equivalent to leaving an empty rear to Soochow. Why does Sun Quan not pick up low cost!
It might be seen from this that the entire Xiangfan battle was a wrong battle launched by Liu Bei Group for a lot of years with smooth sailing and euphoria. The outcome abruptly fell a major heel, not to mention the loss with the common Guan Yu, even the strategic pattern, was also replayed back to the weakest state of Wei Shu Wu three-legged in the state of Shu.
